(Per la scarsità e la natura dei documenti, non è possibile dare la lista completa degli abati, e dei superiori. Si riportano i nomi segnalati dalle fonti disponibili).

Abati benedettini:
Alessandro 1007
Pietro            1029      
Vito                1052
Benedetto    1095
Gualterio      1176
Giovanni di Modena 1310
Giovanni di Offìda   1311
(Cistercense)

Abati Commendatari:
Matteo arcivescovo di Siponto                                                     1327
Guglielmo cardinale dei Santi quattro Coronati                       1342
Giovanni di Guisa monaco di Clairvaut                                     1353
Matteo di S. Bartolomeo di Carpineto                                        1356
Giovanni monaco Cistercense venuto da Ponza                     1364
Don Ludovico Maria Sforza-Colonna                                              ?
Don Vincenzo Carafa                                                                    1578
Cav. Sacchetti                                                                              sec. XVII
Don Carlo Carafa                                                                              “ XVII
Don Antonio Del Giudice                                                                  “ XVII
Don Francesco Del Giudice                                                             “ XVII
Pignatelli cardinale                                                                         1683
Nicola Coscia cardinale                                                             sec. XVIII
Nicola Colonna cardinale                                                          + 1798

Superiori Francescani:
P. Benedetto da S. Marco la Catola                                                                       1788
P. Domenico da Ischitella                                                                                       1790
P. Michele da Rignano Garganico                                                                         1794
P. Serafino da Chieuti                                                                                              1796
P. Antonio da Castelvetere                                                                                      1797
P. Michelantonio da Manfredonia                                                                           1801
P. Giancrisostomo da Manfredonia                                                                       1805
P. Michelantonio da Manfredonia                                                                           1808
P. Benedetto da S. Marco la Catola                                                                        1816
P. Piergiuseppe da Manfredonia                                                                             1819
P. Andrea da Sansevero                                                                                            1823
P. Natale da Foggia                                                                                                    1828
P. Donato da Manfredonia                                                                                        1829
P. Gaetano da Manfredonia                                                                                      1834
P. Luigi da Sansevero                                                                                                1835
P. Gaetano da Biccari                                                                                                 1845
P. Vincenzo da Rodi                                                                                                    1850
P. Gaetano da Biccari                                                                                                  1851
P. Raffaele da Rodi                                                                                                      1853
P. Bernardino da Lucera                                                                                             1856
P. Raffaele da Montecalvo                                                                                           1863
P. Raffaele da Montecalvo                                                                                           1864
P. Antonio Centola da S. Marco in Lamis                                                                  1886
P. Vincenzo Calvitto da S. Marco in Lamis                                                                1890
P. Antonio Centola da S. Marco in Lamis                                                                  1898
P. Luigi da Casalnuovo                                                                                                 1902
P. Vincenzo Levino da Ruvo                                                                                          1905
P. Antonio De Vita da Casalnuovo                                                                               1907
P. Filippo Petracca da Castelnuovo                                                                           1914
P. Antonio De Vita da Casalnuovo                                                                             1918
P. Filippo Petracca da Castelnuovo                                                                           1920
P. Antonio De Vita da Casalnuovo                                                                             1921
P. Bernardino Laricchia da Capurso                                                                         1922
P. Angelico Corbo da Ascoli Satriano                                                                         1924
P. Fedele Brandonisio da Valenzano                                                                          1924
P. Gerardo De Rubertis da Montecilfone                                                                    1927
P. Bernardino Laricchia da Capurso                                                                           1930
P. Bernardino Gianfrancesco da Pontelandolfo                                                        1934
P. Daniele Trotta da Bitetto                                                                                            1935
P. Tommaso Pagano da Palo del Colle                                                                       1937
P. Doroteo Forte da Rignano Garganico                                                                      1940
P. Tarcisio Castriotta da Manfredonia                                                                          1943
P. Leonardo lannacci da Rignano Garganico                                                             1946
P. Antonio Taronna da Monte S. Angelo                                                                       1947
P. Leonardo lannacci da Rignano Garganico                                                             1949
P. Aurelio Porzio da Sansevero                                                                                    1952
P. Ruggero Spadavecchia da Ascoli Satriano                                                            1955
P. Vincenzo Gallo da Ascoli Satriano                                                                           1958
P. Vincenzo Gallo da Ascoli Satriano                                                                           1961
P. Angelo Marracino da Volturino                                                                                  1963
P. Nicola De Michele da Montelongo                                                                           1967
P. Nicola De Michele da Montelongo                                                                           1970
P. Nicola De Michele da Montelongo                                                                           1973
P. Nicola De Michele da Montelongo                                                                           1976